In food-processing applications, this technology excels at product recovery and waste reduction.
Food processors often face leftover product in their tanks and pump inlet and discharge lines, leading to messy and wasteful operations. While precision is a top priority in food and beverage processing, many food processors also deal with day-to-day pumping challenges caused by equipment that cannot meet the demand.
Image 1. While finished food products can be messy, their production must be pristine, which is why many food processors are benefiting from the incorporation of eccentric disc pumps into their operations. (Images and graphics courtesy of Mouvex)
Many plants use rotary lobe pumps and external circumferential piston (ECP) pumps, which are a close cousin to lobe varieties but with a different rotor and hub combination. In some cases, the performance of these pumps may fall short in the following areas of food production:
- Product Handling: Lobe pumps produce more shear than desired in some cases, such as when handling low-viscosity or shear-sensitive products. This means delicate products such as yogurt and sauces can be damaged during the transfer process.
- Accuracy: A sauce package that says 12 ounces should contain 12 ounces of product. A lobe pump's potential suction difficulties and constant wear can lead to inaccurate filling.
- Product Loss: Most pumps are unable to properly recover product at the bottom of tanks or at the pump inlet and discharge lines. Lobe pumps also have seals, which are prone to leaks. These leaks could result in product contamination, messy spills and waste, increased maintenance, spoilage and cleanup costs.
For operators looking to maximize their production rates while minimizing ancillary costs, positive displacement eccentric disc pumps could be an ideal alternative to traditional lobe pumps.
The Challenge
The food-processing industry has many real-world examples of improperly applied lobe or ECP pumps that failed to meet the operational requirements of the processor. The following are a few specific cases.
Seal Separation
A globally recognized manufacturer of snack cakes, breads, cookies and crackers was experiencing problems in the cookie-coating line at one of its plants. The pumps used for this process would operate as expected for a short time before experiencing leaks. This resulted in a significant amount of product loss—as much as 100 pounds of chocolate coating every week—with the constant leaks requiring cleanup almost daily. While repairing the malfunctioning pump, the plant's maintenance manager discovered that an accumulation of chocolate coating between the pump's seals was spreading the seals apart, allowing the product to escape the pump.
Image 2. Eccentric disc pumps can be an ideal alternative to traditional lobe pumps in food processing applications.
Volumetric Consistency
A large U.S.-based, private-label food processing and packaging company on the West Coast that specializes in sauces, seasonings, dressings, marinades, soups and dry mixes was experiencing inefficiencies in its operations that were costing it thousands of dollars each day in wasted product. The company was using ECP pumps to fill its six- and nine-ounce sauce pouches. After the pouches are filled, they are weighed to ensure they meet the predetermined weight. Those that meet the weight requirement are sent for shipment, and those that do not are sent off for disposal. While using the lobe pumps, the company experienced a loss of between 15 and 20 percent (300 to 400 pounds of rejected pouches in an eight-hour shift, which is enough to fill a 55-gallon drum) because the pump could not provide the volumetric consistency necessary to fill the pouches appropriately.
Pump Maintenance
A craft brewer located in the Upper Midwest of the U.S. uses a centrifuge to provide the delicate, shear-free product handling that its family of beers requires. When the company purchased its centrifuge, the manufacturer recommended a lobe pump for the operation, which the company's head brewer initially considered. However, he was quickly dissuaded when he asked his peers for their opinion and they told him using a lobe pump would result in thousands of dollars in maintenance costs that would arise from the need to constantly rebuild it.
Figure 1. Side-by-side comparisons illustrate how a series of significant design and operational benefits allow eccentric disc pumps to outperform lobe pumps in many critical food processing applications.
Recovery Rates
Two yogurt manufacturers in the Americas were losing more than $100,000 in product per line per year in their filler-feed lines. With the incorporation of eccentric disc pumps, the plants experienced recovery rates of more than 70 percent.
Technology Challenges
Because of their method of operation—the rotation of the lobes forces the pumped material to flow around the interior of the pump cavity—lobe pumps experience continual wear. This means that the internal clearances in the pump housing become more pronounced over time, resulting in reduced flow capacity and volumetric consistency as pressures and product viscosities change. This constant wear can also increase the likelihood of product slip.
Image 3. The eccentric movement principle drives eccentric disc pumps, which use a disc inside the pump cylinder that is driven by an eccentric bearing on the pump shaft, creating four distinct pumping chambers. This produces a regular flow rate with no pulsing, cavitation, slip or shear.
For a food processing operation that may use the same pump to transfer different products, these pumps are also often unable to adequately strip lines, which is another critical consideration.
Lobe/ECP pumps have two shafts that must be sealed. This doubles the number of areas where leaks can occur. Their self-draining capability requires vertical porting, which can result in as much as a 25 percent decrease in volumetric consistency. Lobe pumps are not self-priming and can run dry for only a short period of time. Without lubricated seals, lobe pumps must operate at greatly reduced speeds in order to handle high-viscosity liquids, and they can experience diminished performance when handling low-viscosity liquids.
Table 1. Incorporating increased energy efficiency into food processing operations is one way to reduce operating costs. This chart shows how much money is consumed per positive displacement pump, if the cost for energy is $0.10 per kilowatt hour (KwH).
Table 2. Useable raw materials or saleable finished products that cannot be recovered from inlet or discharge lines is akin to flushing money down the drain. Utilizing eccentric disc pumps presents an opportunity for food processors to maximize their product recovery rates, leading to significant annual cost savings, as the chart above illustrates.
The Solution
Eccentric disc pump technology operates on the eccentric movement principle developed by French engineer Andre Petit. Petit's pump design features a disc that is placed inside a pump cylinder. The disc is driven by an eccentric bearing on the pump shaft, creating four distinct pumping chambers that increase and decrease in volume as the disc is rotated by the eccentric bearing. This movement produces both suction and discharge pressures as the chambers move in pairs that are 180 degrees apart. This ensures that the fluid passes through the pump at a constant and regular flow rate with no pulsing, cavitation, slip or shear.
Some eccentric disc pumps can pump air when no fluid is present. This creates a vacuum effect on the pump's suction side and a compressor effect on the discharge side. Once the product runs out in the feed tank, the eccentric disc technology continues to pump air in a constant, non-abrupt, non-pulsating manner so that the surface tension on any remaining fluid is not broken. This produces a plug effect, which pushes out the product "plug" as a whole.
One significant area in which the incorporation of eccentric disc pumps can have significant results is product recovery. Product waste in hygienic food processing is an area that incurs extremely high costs. The McKinsey Quarterly Food Waste Alliance has reported that more than $120 billion of product goes to waste worldwide annually. The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) also estimates that the U.S. is losing 40 percent of its food from farm to fork to landfills. Between farm and fork are the processing plants that manufacture some of these products.
While many food processors turn to reduced energy expenditures as a way to reduce operational costs, eccentric disc pumps with a minimum product recovery capability of 70 percent have been shown to produce significantly higher annual savings. Product waste is a severe handicap to the manufacturer's bottom line, and product recovery is an opportunity to limit waste and gain cost savings.
The typical amount of product recovered by eccentric disc pump technology can be more than 95 percent on the suction side of the pump and typically 60 to 80 percent on the discharge side.
When used in food and beverage manufacturing operations, the eccentric disc pump serves as the normal process pump, with its product-recovery capability adding cost-saving value to the operation in the form of recovered and still usable raw materials or saleable finished products.
About the Author
Paul Cardon is the industry product manager for Mouvex, part of PSG. Headquartered in Auxerre, France, Mouvex is a brand of positive displacement pumps and compressors from PSG, a Dover company. Cardon may be reached at paul.cardon@psgdover.com or +33 3 8649 8696. For more information, visit mouvex.com and psgdover.com.